A buttermilk short stack is a diner classic for good reason . But no pauperization to riff if you do n’t have any — we have 3 brilliant reserve you may taste instead .
Jason Donnelly
If you glint around ourbreakfast recipearchives , you ’ll notice this ingredient makes a frequent appearance , but does n’t get nigh as much love after lunch : buttermilk . This tangy dairy product contributes to our recipes raking in reviews like “ the full pancakes ever ! ! ” ( Classic Buttermilk Pancakes ) and “ astonishingly fluffy , and so delicious ” ( Buttermilk Pancakes ) .

Credit:Jason Donnelly
You ’ll also spy buttermilk inBHGteam favorites likeCornmeal Buttermilk Waffles with Honey ButterandButtermilk - Banana Waffles . Although we ~flip~ over each of these recipes frequently , it ’s been a while since we took time to contemplate on what stool them stand out from other batter blends made with other dairy type ( orplant - ground Milk River alternatives ) .
Read on to find out why buttermilk is a staple in so many pancake andwaffle formula , to learn what to do if you do n’t have any on mitt for your breakfast ( orbreakfast for dinner party ) , and to discover buttermilk recipes that think outside of the breakfast boxwood .
What is Buttermilk, Exactly?
Traditionally , buttermilk was the high - protein liquid leftover from the butter - making process , explainsSarah Brekke , M.S.,Better Homes & GardensTest Kitchen sword manager .
“ These days , the cultured buttermilk you find at the supermarket is a concoction of milk and participating bacteria cultures that has been lightly heated for about 12 hours to allow it to ferment , ” she says .
As the milk fit through fermentation , it thickens and becomes more acidic due to the geological formation oflactic acid . It also begins to take on a rich buttery flavor due to the creation of a molecule calleddiacetyl , Brekke sum up . ( Diacetyl is find in minuscule amount in butter and fresh cheeses , too . )

Credit: Andy Lyons
Why Buttermilk Is a Staple In Pancake and Waffle Recipes
Those two newfangled constituent — lactic loony toons and diacetyl — make buttermilk an MVP in waffles and pancakes . consort to Brekke :
Is Buttermilk Essential for Pancake and Waffle Batter?
In our guide forhow to make pancake , we offer variations forplain pancakesthat call for milk instead of buttermilk , and ourHoney - Lemon Cottage Cheese Pancakesinclude voguish bungalow cheese plus some lemon gusto for a tart , fresh boost . Zoe ’s Creme Fraiche Pancakesget their magnificence from a intermixture of whole Milk River , sour cream , and creme fraiche .
So , no , “ buttermilk is n’t essential , ” Brekke confirms . However , “ we do palpate that there is a classic flavour and grain you’re able to only find in a buttermilk pancake or waffle that ’s laborious to match with a buttermilk substitute or milk alone . ”
The Best Buttermilk Substitutes for Waffle and Pancake Recipes
Ideally , if a formula calls for buttermilk , including a pancake or waffle formula , you should use it . But if you find yourself without the ingredient , you could rely on one of ourbest buttermilk fill-in :
“ All of these alternatives will work , " Brekke say . " The Greek yoghurt hack generally results in the serious flavor , though . It ’s resonant of the tangy flavor that buttermilk lends . "
Our Best Buttermilk Recipe Ideas That Prove It’s Good For More Than Pancakes and Waffles
If you decide to stock up on store - bought buttermilk for waffle and pancakes and do n’t polish it off , you have plenty of options . Cook and bake your way through17 tasty buttermilk recipe ideas .
diffident of where to set out ? research the all-encompassing world of buttermilk formula that are among Brekke ’s darling :

Credit: Andy Lyons